[Review] Five Decembers by James Kestrel
Oct. 28th, 2024 12:05 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Title: Five Decembers
Author: James Kestrel
Genre: historical mystery/crime/hardboiled detective/noir fiction
Publication date: 2021
Publisher: Hard Case Crime
Length: 429 pages
Content Warnings: graphic violence and description of gruesome murder scene which involved torture, war and prisoner of war camp conditions, one mention of abortion which was so unexpected, so brief, so indirect, and so casual it felt like a slap from an invisible hand (and was never mentioned again! bizarre!), sexual scenes
( Cover - NSFW - Mild nudity and sexual setting and a gun )
Summary: Police detective Joe McGrady is assigned to investigate a homicide in Honolulu, Hawaii in December 1941. The book follows McGrady for five years as he travels from Hawaii to Hong Kong to Tokyo and back on the trail of a violent killer whose crimes it is revealed are part of a conspiracy. Just after McGrady leaves Honolulu, Pearl Harbor is bombed, and he is cut off from return. He is framed for aggravated rape in Hong Kong and put in prison but escapes and makes his way to Tokyo and hides in the home of a Japanese politician related to the original homicide case. He solves the case and returns home (where he's been declared dead for years) and then makes a final decision about his future.
Analysis: It's a hero's journey story. The identity of the killer and the way the killer is connected to the larger world at war is revealed chapter by chapter. The reader follows Joe across the Pacific Ocean from island to island as he puts the case together and deals with the many dangers that confront him and calamities that befall him (and women who he falls in love with and has sex with).
Recommendation: The major drawback about this story is that it is All About a White Dude. That said, I really enjoyed the case itself. I felt it was compelling and well-crafted with just enough twists and surprises. I enjoyed learning about a part of history and a part of the globe which I know very little about. I read almost exclusively detective fiction, and I liked that part of it. I didn't enjoy so much Joe's relationships with women. And when the case is over, I was rolling my eyes about what Joe decides to do. Spoiler alert: love wins all *wah!* It's a long book, so it is a commitment. And at times, I had the sense that Joe was a kind of Detective Forest Gump, so many bad things happen to him, but he manages to survive and keep going. In the beginning, it's a bit like CSI with a gruesome murder scene, and then it's like every police procedural you've ever read with chain-of-command politics and pressure from above. But, still, I would recommend it if you enjoy the hardboiled detective genre. The setting was novel (to me) and the plotting was good, and Joe is likable guy.
Author: James Kestrel
Genre: historical mystery/crime/hardboiled detective/noir fiction
Publication date: 2021
Publisher: Hard Case Crime
Length: 429 pages
Content Warnings: graphic violence and description of gruesome murder scene which involved torture, war and prisoner of war camp conditions, one mention of abortion which was so unexpected, so brief, so indirect, and so casual it felt like a slap from an invisible hand (and was never mentioned again! bizarre!), sexual scenes
( Cover - NSFW - Mild nudity and sexual setting and a gun )
Summary: Police detective Joe McGrady is assigned to investigate a homicide in Honolulu, Hawaii in December 1941. The book follows McGrady for five years as he travels from Hawaii to Hong Kong to Tokyo and back on the trail of a violent killer whose crimes it is revealed are part of a conspiracy. Just after McGrady leaves Honolulu, Pearl Harbor is bombed, and he is cut off from return. He is framed for aggravated rape in Hong Kong and put in prison but escapes and makes his way to Tokyo and hides in the home of a Japanese politician related to the original homicide case. He solves the case and returns home (where he's been declared dead for years) and then makes a final decision about his future.
Analysis: It's a hero's journey story. The identity of the killer and the way the killer is connected to the larger world at war is revealed chapter by chapter. The reader follows Joe across the Pacific Ocean from island to island as he puts the case together and deals with the many dangers that confront him and calamities that befall him (and women who he falls in love with and has sex with).
Recommendation: The major drawback about this story is that it is All About a White Dude. That said, I really enjoyed the case itself. I felt it was compelling and well-crafted with just enough twists and surprises. I enjoyed learning about a part of history and a part of the globe which I know very little about. I read almost exclusively detective fiction, and I liked that part of it. I didn't enjoy so much Joe's relationships with women. And when the case is over, I was rolling my eyes about what Joe decides to do. Spoiler alert: love wins all *wah!* It's a long book, so it is a commitment. And at times, I had the sense that Joe was a kind of Detective Forest Gump, so many bad things happen to him, but he manages to survive and keep going. In the beginning, it's a bit like CSI with a gruesome murder scene, and then it's like every police procedural you've ever read with chain-of-command politics and pressure from above. But, still, I would recommend it if you enjoy the hardboiled detective genre. The setting was novel (to me) and the plotting was good, and Joe is likable guy.